Views: 80

Part 2 of the AI, Law & Talent series examines two sets of rules that can affect employers using AI in hiring. New York City regulates covered automated employment decision tools through Local Law 144. The EU AI Act applies a risk-based framework, with specific duties for providers and organisations that deploy covered systems.

What NYC Local Law 144 Covers

New York City began enforcing Local Law 144 on July 5, 2023. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) regulates automated employment decision tools (AEDTs) used in the city to screen candidates for hiring or employees for promotion.

The test depends on how the output is used. The DCWP FAQ explains that a covered tool produces a simplified output, such as a score, classification or recommendation, that substantially assists or replaces discretionary decision-making. Examples include relying on the output alone, weighting it more heavily than any other criterion, or using it to override conclusions reached through other factors. A tool that only stores applications or contacts prospective applicants serves a different function.

Check the job location, how remote positions are assigned and who must receive notice. Candidate residency and the location of the job are separate considerations. Record what the tool does in your workflow, including how recruiters use its output.

Three Requirements Before Using a Covered AEDT

1. Verify the Independent Bias Audit

Ensure an independent auditor completed a bias audit within one year before use. The DCWP FAQ describes the required analysis for selection or scoring rates and impact ratios across sex, race and ethnicity, and relevant combinations of those categories. A vendor can arrange an independent audit. The employer or employment agency remains responsible for checking that an applicable audit was done.

2. Publish the Audit Summary and Distribution Date

Make the most recent audit summary and the date you began using the tool publicly available through the employment section of your website or an active link there. The summary includes the audit date, an explanation of the data used, and the required counts, rates and impact ratios. Use the published summary to check that the audit applies to the tool you are using.

3. Give Notice and Explain How to Request Help

Provide the required notice to New York City residents at least 10 business days before use. State that an AEDT will be used, list the job qualifications or characteristics assessed, and explain how to request an alternative selection process or accommodation. Use a notice method permitted for the hiring or promotion workflow.

Local Law 144 allows people to request an alternative process. Its notice provision does not itself require an employer to grant every request. Separate accommodation laws may require action. The law also provides for disclosure of the types and sources of data and the retention policy, including a written-request process if the information is unavailable on the website. Check the DCWP page and its links to the law and implementing rule for the details.

Example Notice to Adapt With Your Hiring Team

[Employer] uses [tool] to assist in evaluating applications for [role]. The tool assesses [list the actual job qualifications or characteristics]. For instructions on requesting an alternative selection process or reasonable accommodation, contact [monitored contact]. The audit summary and distribution date are available at [public page]. Information on the types and sources of data and our retention policy is available at [page or request contact].

Replace all placeholders and confirm that the notice is accurate and available through a permitted channel at least 10 business days before use. Test who receives and responds to requests.

How the EU AI Act Applies to Recruitment

The European Commission’s AI Act overview identifies certain employment uses, such as AI used to sort CVs, as high-risk. Classification depends on the intended purpose and applicable exceptions. Check the territorial scope and where the system or its output is used. An EU office alone does not establish coverage for every hiring workflow worldwide.

According to the European Commission’s enforcement timeline, the high-risk requirements for Annex III systems apply from 2 December 2027. Other provisions follow their own schedules. Identify whether your organisation is the provider, the deployer, or both before assigning responsibilities.

  • Providers: Review requirements for risk management, documentation, logging, oversight, conformity assessment and post-market monitoring as applicable.
  • Deployers: Review instructions for use, assign competent human oversight, monitor operation, manage logs under your control, and assess applicable information duties for workers or individuals affected by decisions.
  • Explanations: Review whether the Act’s right to an explanation applies to the specific decision. Define who can explain how the system contributed and what evidence the reviewer considered.

Enforcement, Evidence and Budget

DCWP accepts complaints about required audits, public summaries and notices. A 2024 field study of Local Law 144 documented difficulties determining which employers used covered tools and locating disclosures. The study’s observations do not establish how many employers violated the law.

NYC civil penalties depend on the violation and its circumstances. EU AI Act penalties vary by the provision, the party and applicable limits. The Act’s highest penalty tier concerns prohibited practices. For a budget, get quotes for the audit and legal review, then estimate staff time for collecting data, publishing results, maintaining notices, handling requests and monitoring changes.

Five Steps to Review Your Hiring Workflow

1. Inventory Tools and How the Team Uses Them

List résumé scoring, assessments, video analysis, matching and automation features. Record each feature’s purpose, who uses it and the weight its output carries. Map coverage by role, location and workflow.

2. Verify Audit Coverage

Identify who commissioned the audit, who conducted it, which system it covered and when it was completed. Have the auditor explain the data and metrics. Evaluate disparities with the appropriate legal and hiring teams.

3. Set Up Notices and Requests

Publish or deliver the appropriate notice on time. Assign an owner for accommodation and alternative-process requests and test the contact path before deployment.

4. Publish and Maintain the Audit Summary

Check the public page as an applicant would. Verify that the summary opens without a login, matches the deployed tool and includes the required information. Set a reminder to check the audit date and review material changes to the workflow.

5. Document Human Oversight

Show reviewers how to verify evidence, override recommendations and handle exceptions. Keep records of significant decisions and changes. Review other jurisdictions and applicable disability, privacy and employment requirements before rollout.

How Explainability Supports Review

A clear explanation helps a recruiter see why the system suggested a match and check what evidence supports it. Use that alongside testing, oversight, documentation and any legally required audit. Ask whether recruiters can identify errors, challenge the output and explain their own final decision.

Evaluate EDLIGO AIRA

Hiring teams can review how AIRA’s recruiting agents compare a résumé with job requirements and present the rationale for a match. Outplacement teams and job seekers can use résumé and role-fit feedback to discuss transferable skills and prepare for interviews. Ask EDLIGO to demonstrate the outputs and records available for your specific workflow.

Book an AIRA demo to discuss your hiring process and review requirements.

Read the Rest of the Series

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner