Views: 154

Part 1 of the AI, Law & Talent series examines what litigation over automated hiring means for employers and software vendors. Mobley v. Workday illustrates how a court can examine a vendor’s role and allow applicants to pursue an age discrimination claim together before deciding the merits.

What the Court Decided in Mobley v. Workday

July 2024: The Vendor’s Role in Screening

Derek Mobley sued Workday in February 2023. He alleged that he applied to more than 100 positions at employers using Workday’s tools and that their screening process discriminated against him based on age, race and disability. In its July 12, 2024 order, the federal district court concluded that the allegations plausibly supported treating Workday as an employer’s agent under federal discrimination statutes. It allowed certain disparate-impact claims to proceed at the pleading stage. That ruling addressed the sufficiency of the allegations.

May 2025: Preliminary Certification of the Age Collective

On May 16, 2025, Judge Rita F. Lin granted preliminary collective certification under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. The order covers eligible applicants aged 40 or older who, from September 24, 2020 onward, applied for jobs and were denied employment recommendations through the Workday screening tools at issue. Preliminary certification lets eligible applicants opt in. It establishes neither that discrimination occurred nor how many applicants might recover damages.

An October 7, 2026 discovery order records a separate September motion for class certification. The order addresses discovery and describes the age collective as conditionally certified.

What the Case Tells Us About Financial Exposure

The court orders cited here provide no basis for the earlier $25 billion and $50 billion figures. Multiplying an assumed number of applicants by an assumed award cannot establish how many people are eligible, which claims will succeed or what remedies may apply. For budgeting, estimate audit, monitoring and remediation costs from the actual tools and workflows in use.

What Other Evidence Shows

Automated Age Screening and the iTutorGroup Settlement

In 2023, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission announced a $365,000 settlement with iTutorGroup. The agency alleged that application software automatically rejected women aged 55 or older and men aged 60 or older, excluding more than 200 qualified applicants. Review which rules can automatically reject candidates and whether each rule is job-related.

Accessibility in Video and Speech Assessments

Check whether an assessment measures skills required for the role and whether applicants can request accommodations. A test that relies on speech, motion or facial expression can introduce barriers unrelated to job performance. The NYC Commission on Human Rights disability guidance discusses accessibility and accommodation in employment assessments.

Bias in Résumé Rankings

University of Washington researchers varied names on résumés in a retrieval experiment using three language models. The university reported that the tested models favoured White-associated names in 85% of comparisons. The result is specific to the experiment. Use controlled checks to see whether your tool treats equivalent qualifications differently.

How to Review Screening Risk

Document Job Criteria and Decisions

Disparate treatment and disparate impact are distinct legal theories. A facially neutral screening rule can warrant review even where discriminatory intent is not alleged. Record what each rule measures, why it matters for the role, and which evidence the reviewer can inspect.

  • Identify where scores, recommendations or automatic rejections affect the workflow.
  • Review a sample of low-ranked or rejected applications for missed qualifications.
  • Give reviewers authority to challenge outputs and record reasons for overrides.
  • Confirm which evaluation records, model versions and change notices the vendor can provide.

Include Rehiring and Internal Mobility

Former employees who reapply may be evaluated by a new workflow. Check whether it recognises relevant prior experience, who reviews exceptions and whether the same standards apply to comparable candidates. Extend the review to promotion and internal mobility where relevant.

Where Hiring Rules Apply

NYC Local Law 144 guidance explains bias audits, public summaries and notices for covered automated employment decision tools. Coverage depends on how and where a tool is used.

The European Commission’s AI Act overview identifies certain recruitment and selection uses as high-risk. The Commission’s enforcement timeline lists 2 December 2027 for high-risk systems covered by Annex III. Check the intended use and applicable obligations with your legal team.

How Explainable Outputs Can Help Reviewers

EDLIGO AIRA offers tools for CV analysis, job matching, interview preparation and job description review. In a pilot, check whether recruiters can trace match explanations to the job requirements and the application. Use those outputs alongside human oversight, accessibility testing and applicable audits.

Outplacement teams can use CV and role-fit feedback to discuss transferable skills. AIRA for Job Seekers helps applicants compare their experience with a target role and prepare for interviews.

Book an AIRA demo to see what information reviewers can inspect.

Continue the AI, Law & Talent Series

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner